A few months ago I killed a severely injured adolescent rabbit by striking it with a broad wide shovel. Why, then, can I not make myself to do something similar — end pain — for a dying goat?
I am reminded of the amazing essay “Death of a Pig,” by E. B. White: “I spent several days and nights in mid-September with an ailing pig and I feel driven to account for this stretch of time, more particularly since the pig died at last, and I lived, and things might easily have gone the other way round and none left to do the accounting.”
Just as White’s pig failed to show up at suppertime one day, the littlest goat did not scamper into the yard to see me, and by doing so let me know that his health had changed. By the time I noticed him standing uncertain in the barn doorway, or later, when we saw the signs of anemia, and brown-green excrement stuck thickly to his tail, time may have already run out. I don’t know. “A sick goat is a dead goat” is an adage among those who raise these animals.
He was the runt of four bucklings we bought last spring, the last to wean from bottle-feeding and always lowest in the pecking order. His most memorable trait was poking at people standing in the barn in hopes that milk would appear as it would from his mother. In the last week I have watched the larger two bucklings charge at him so hard near the alfalfa that he has toppled to the side. I imagine that out of my sight, this has been happening for many weeks, increasing the difference in their rapid gain in strength and his weakening.
For his last 48 hours, we isolated the goat in a large pen with fresh straw, alfalfa and water. We turned on a heat lamp and he stood beneath the bulb, shivering. I went to visit several times. Late on Thanksgiving, he spread himself in the straw, back and neck slightly arched. His bleats turned garbled and warbled. I knelt beside him many times, knowing he was uncomfortable. As though he were a friend, I patted his head and willed him to let go and die.
This may seem like much ado over the death of a farm animal, particularly one that was obviously the weakest of the herd. What bothers me — what, as White said, keeps the goat’s death steady “in the bowl of my mind,” is the fact that I could end the suffering of a partially skinned rabbit crying out in the barnyard, but I could not do the same for the goat. I could not shoot the animal, nor slit its throat, as would have been more humane than leaving him lying there in the clean straw, eyes lackluster, for the final 24 hours.
The sun is beginning to come up, and we’ll soon go to the barn to remove the body. I know that death is a part of farming, as it is a part of all living, but it seems to me that I should have done more, or could have, to either prevent it or make death come more quickly.




