This blog is about an experiment in farming on one level and an experiment in writing on another. Or both on the same level, but I’ve kept them very much either/or. I suppose this is schizophrenic. The storytelling about the farm is comfortable, and I like nesting there. There are other things to tackle, though, for this online experiment to work. My hope is that writing about writing, especially posts about blogging, don’t scare you away.
I’ve been asked how this blog is art, how is it literature. One can graduate with a master of fine arts in creative writing with a collection of fiction, poems, essays, or go for the full novel. So where does a blog fit into this, and how is it art the way that a university might define a novel or collection to be art?
A few weeks ago, Susan M. Schultz wrote about the question of blog literature:
So what is blog lit? In order to get to the answer, we need to think about what a blog makes possible. Rather than defining blogs by what people have done with them (written diaries, outed racist politicians), why not think of them as a kind of genre? Just as “the novel” or “non-fiction” or “book” contain multiple generic possibilities, so does the blog. It’s simply a container for writing, but a container that is limited and enabled by its rules and those of the software that helps the non-computer literate to create one.
This idea of blogging as a container intrigues me, because it keeps all the possibility I associate with other genres. Within the framework, the container, of what we think of a novel, can be a narrative written forward in time, backwards or spliced together. It can be a series of letters, from multiple points of view, as chapters or not. These are just structural variances, “allowed” by readers if the novel is well written, if it is an artful work. A blog be a container with such variation, too.
This is a fundamental question. I typically think of blog posts as having an arc, of telling a story, whether by word or image or both, but I also am drawn to blogs that are mere snippets of thoughts and information. I have resisted writing the latter here, for concern that it is not artful enough. If I go off on tangents or write unedited, on impulse, unimpeded by these rules I have made up for art in the thesis sense, what would I create? This means letting go of the idea that if it isn’t artful enough, then perhaps it doesn’t count as the art of an MFA thesis. I haven’t given myself the permission to do anything outside of what I think is acceptable for a thesis. Time to break that rule.
October 1, 2009 at 3:17 am
I haven’t given myself the permission to do anything outside of what I think is acceptable
Speaking from experience, I find that you are at your best when you step outside the so-called permissible zone. I like the Jen that comes out when unconstrained by convention, rules, and obligation. Sometimes it takes a little Knob Creek and some loud music to get there though, yes?
ps. Your post about visiting your dad almost brought tears to my eyes, how I wished I could have joined you all checking out the pond and the woodshop and the complete quiet of that country space. Can you convince Steve to join us for Thanksgiving this year?
October 1, 2009 at 5:58 pm
Jen–thanks for the quotation! There’s another blog lit MFA project that I know of, here:
http://thetoleranceproject.blogspot.com/
Very different from yours, hence a fascinating test of the form.
aloha, Susan
October 1, 2009 at 10:54 pm
“this feels like a ‘breakthrough post’” – OK, I’m parodying workshop-speak. But there’s a lot of insight in this one.
“If I go off on tangents or write unedited, on impulse, unimpeded by these rules I have made up for art in the thesis sense, what would I create? This means letting go of the idea that if it isn’t artful enough, then perhaps it doesn’t count as the art of an MFA thesis.”
Depends on whom you ask. If you’re taking your cues from someone with a rather conservative notion of what The Essay is and is not, then yeah. For me, ironically, following this template ends up making this blog a lot like a lot of other blogs (albeit much better wordsmithing than most). Is that enough? For what? What’s “lit”? That word is kind of an honorific – to that extent, it gets in the way.
Tangents, impulse, unimpeded, letting go: right on. Personally, to me, those sorts of things lead to art more surely than all the rules in the rule book of writing. Which I guess is another way of saying I’m a Romantic, not a classicist (gods help me).
IMAGINATION is not incompatible with form. In fact, can lead to new forms.
October 2, 2009 at 9:19 pm
It’s fascinating to see your navigation process here! I’m thinking back to a a few conversations we had at Free State when you were still working to find support for your blog-as-thesis endeavor (yay, Joe!). You pushed and pushed against the department’s inertia to be able to go in the direction you’ve taken, but now I think you’re bumping into your own inherited views of what “counts,” so to speak, as lit, as thesis, etc. You’re used to working (beautifully) with the essay, but it strikes me that a benefit of the blog-as-container understanding is that you can push beyond the essay and post exactly those musings, tangents, impulses, etc. as those will likely provoke the interactivity you want for this site and, I’d wager, plant the seeds–appropriately–for future essays and farm/life endeavors.
October 5, 2009 at 2:11 pm
Thanks for the encouragement. I’m generally risk averse – in writing and in life in general, so it takes a lot of motivation, pushing myself and allowing myself the freedom to explore. Getting there, slowly, but the journey is a good one.
November 6, 2009 at 3:49 am
Risk averse??! This from the person who is doing a BLOG as her MFA thesis? While holding a responsible full-time job AND running a farm in rural Kansas with her lover??? Maybe that’s so much of the landscape that you don’t see it any more, but to me, that does NOT say “risk averse.” Excelsior!
March 29, 2010 at 11:21 am
[...] favorite of the comments: Joe Harrington, responding to blog lit post: “Risk averse??! This from the person who is doing a BLOG as her MFA thesis? While holding a [...]